24°CChennaiCloudy
News

High Court seeks State reply on clubs’ plea against bottle buy-back

A liquor licensees' association has challenged the 2022 circular making clubs return members' empty bottles, and the new ₹10 cess. The court wants replies.

Clubs challenge TASMAC bottle buy-back rules
Photo: sergeitokmakov / Pixabay

A licensees’ association wants the 2022 circular that makes clubs return members’ empty bottles to TASMAC quashed, and the High Court has asked the State to respond.

Clubs can gather the bottles emptied on their premises. Getting them back from members’ homes is another matter, and that is the heart of a writ petition now before Justice N Senthilkumar of the Madras High Court.

The court has asked the Tamil Nadu government and the managing director of TASMAC to file responses. The petitioner is the secretary of a trade association of liquor licence holders, among them FL.2 clubs and FL.3 licensees.

The circular dates from August 2022

What the association wants struck down is a circular of 2 August 2022 issued by the Commissioner of Prohibition and Excise. It requires registered societies to collect empty liquor bottles from their members and return them to TASMAC. It also attacks the circulars and notifications that followed it, including requirements on reverse vending machines and the Environmental and Social Welfare Cess.

The grounds are spelt out at length. The association says the circular was issued without proper guidelines, causes hardship to societies and affects their right to carry on business. It argues that retrieving bottles from members’ private residences is practically impossible, the more so because members include prominent public figures. The reverse vending and cess measures, it says, contradict each other and cost licensees money. And it says the ₹10-per-container cess under the Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax Act, 2006, was imposed without a matching change to the input tax credit rules for the assessment period. It accepts that the buy-back was introduced for social welfare on High Court directions, but argues it should not cause business or revenue losses to one industry.

Replies are awaited.

The ₹10 moved into the price on 1 November

The cess the petition objects to is new law. L.A. Bill No. 14 of 2026, published in the Gazette on 7 August 2026, amends the VAT Act to allow a cess of up to ₹20 per unit container of liquor, at a rate the government fixes by notification. The Bill defines a unit container widely: a bottle, jar, flask, pot, tin, can, tetra pack or any similar receptacle.

TASMAC’s circular of 29 October then folded ₹10 into the maximum retail price from 1 November 2026, described as including the environmental and social welfare cess. So a bottle priced at ₹170 now sells for ₹180. Customers no longer pay a separate ₹10 at the counter, and shop staff have been told not to collect anything above the revised MRP for the scheme. The refund stays: return an eligible empty and the ₹10 comes back. The circular also revised prices for liquor supplied to the licensed premises the association represents.

Date Step
15 May 2022 Buy-back begins in the Nilgiris
2 August 2022 Commissioner’s circular on clubs returning bottles
7 August 2026 VAT amendment Bill allows cess up to ₹20 a container
1 November 2026 ₹10 folded into MRP across Tamil Nadu

Source: Policy Note 2024-25, Home, Prohibition and Excise Department; Gazette No. 343 of 2026; TASMAC circular of 29 October 2026

For Context

The scheme began in the hills. The Home, Prohibition and Excise Department’s policy note for 2024-25 says TASMAC introduced it over environmental concerns about discarded glass bottles, in line with directions of the High Court, refunding the ₹10 collected over the MRP when an empty is returned. It started in the Nilgiris (நீலகிரி) on 15 May 2022 and was extended from 15 June 2022 to Coimbatore North, Coimbatore South and Dharmapuri, later reaching Kanniyakumari, Nagapattinam, Perambalur, Theni, Thiruvarur and other hilly regions. The court’s first direction came in April 2022 from a Division Bench hearing a batch of cases on protecting the Western Ghats.

From there it spread district by district, including Kancheepuram and Tiruvallur on the Chennai fringe in 2025. In December 2025 TASMAC told a special bench that the scheme was fully running in 22 districts and partly in six.

Checked against official sources on 15 November 2026.

Sources

  1. Tamil Nadu Government Gazette Extraordinary No. 343, Part IV Section 1, L.A. Bill No. 14 of 2026 to amend the Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax Act, 2006, 7 August 2026
  2. Prohibition and Excise, Policy Note 2024-2025, Home, Prohibition and Excise Department, Government of Tamil Nadu (section 5.22, bottle buy-back)
  3. Order of Justice N Senthilkumar seeking responses from the State and TASMAC on a writ petition against the bottle buy-back circulars, November 2026 (Madras High Court)
  4. TASMAC circular of 29 October 2026 on revised MRP from 1 November 2026 (Tamil Nadu State Marketing Corporation)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *